Ontario's Government by Bulldozer
This column was previously published in the Barrie Advance.
The provincial government has decided to raise the minimum wage, and are finally admitting that they don’t care if it hurts small businesses or puts people out of work.
On December 7, Liberal MPP Ann Hoggarth was in her riding of Barrie when she said the following about small businesses that may go out of business because of the minimum wage hike: “if you’re going to go out of business, because on the backs of your employees [sic], because you can’t afford to pay them this, perhaps you should reassess your business plan and reassess if you should be an employer at all.”
Ann Hoggarth was elected in 2014, and was previously an elementary school teacher and local union chapter president. And obviously, a self-taught expert on how to run a small business.
Keep in mind, the Ontario Chamber of Commerce (OCC) is not even opposed to increasing the minimum wage. Rather, they are concerned that the planned increase is “too much, too fast,” and that the pace is just too difficult for small businesses to absorb. Vice President of the OCC, Karl Baldauf, has pointed out that while the intent of the wage increase may be good, a $15 minimum wage took five years to implement in California and four years in Seattle. In Ontario, the government is requiring a 32 per cent increase in 18 months.
Many small businesses operate on narrow margins, and have close relationships with their employees. The statement by MPP Hoggarth shows a lack of concern for the real world experiences of business owners and the people they employ.
Small business owners risk their own capital to create something of value. With narrow margins, they need to plan how to use their limited resources. For Hoggarth to say they ought not to be in business and their workers become unemployed if the owners can’t operate on government timelines, is callous and out of touch, but fitting for a politician who has never created a private-sector job herself.
This attitude is also par for the course for a government that is keen to impose their viewpoints on the province without much concern about the implications for anything other than their electoral prospects.
Or consider residential electricity reforms. The temporary rate reduction financed with as much as $39.4 billion in borrowing will see prices soar after four years, according to the Liberal’s own leaked documents. These reforms show little concern for the long term, but temporary relief helps to set the government up for the June 2018 election.
The government has acted as if adding billions in debt to what is already the most indebted sub-national borrower in the world was the only option available to lower rates. They simply ignore that part of the reason rates are so high is that their own ideological Green Energy Act forced consumers to overpay for electricity by $37 billion between 2006 and 2014.
The minimum wage increase is just the latest example of governing by the bulldozer method. No matter who it hurts, no matter what the cost or consequences, Wynne will move ahead with policies that align with her ideology. Especially if they’ll help them get re-elected. The only difference, is that this time Hoggarth admitted it.