The government shouldn’t do things it isn’t good at because resources get wasted and problems don’t get solved.
The federal government is not good at banning and confiscating firearms. It costs too much. And police say it won’t make Canadians safer.
Ottawa should have listened to the law-enforcement experts who say it should scrap this failing scheme. Instead, there’s rumblings that it will double down and dramatically increase the bill for taxpayers by going after one specific rifle: the SKS.
The government first announced the scheme and started banning guns in 2020. It took more than five years for the government to start confiscating them with a pilot project in Cape Breton in 2025. That pilot project confiscated 25 firearms. The government’s goal was to confiscate 200.
The projected costs for the program increased too.
The Liberal party said the confiscation would cost $200 million in 2019. The Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated compensation alone could cost up to $756 million, excluding administration. The government’s current projection is about $742 million.
And experts say it won’t make Canadians safer.
“Buyback programs are largely ineffective at reducing gun violence, in large part because the people who participate in such programs are not likely to use those guns to commit violence,” said University of Toronto professor Jooyoung Lee, who studies gun violence.
The government doesn’t have any evidence that the expensive policy will work.
The Canadian Taxpayers Federation filed an access-to-information request with Public Safety Canada, the department in charge of the confiscation. The request asked for “all analysis from the department on the efficacy of the assault style firearms compensation program and its effect on crime rates/public safety.”
The department said, “No information related to your request exists within Public Safety Canada.” That means the government didn’t check if its gun ban will make Canadians safer.
It’s clear the government isn’t very good at this.
But it increasingly looks like the SKS rifle is next on the government’s chopping block. The government tried to ban it once before and studied banning it again last year, recommending further studies. Liberal member of Parliament Nathalie Provost has also called for banning the SKS.
The SKS is a popular rifle for hunters and sport shooters across Canada. If you know someone with a firearms licence, there’s a good chance they own an SKS.
There are anywhere from 500,000 to one million SKS rifles in Canada, according to estimates. The government’s current confiscation is attempting to confiscate just under 69,000 firearms.
If the government managed to confiscate 500,000 SKSs at $700 per rifle, it would cost taxpayers about an extra $350 million in compensation.
And this estimate for the SKS doesn’t include the extra costs of administration, salaries, transport and everything else.
SKS is also hugely popular with Indigenous hunters.
The last time the government tried to ban the SKS, the Assembly of First Nations passed an emergency resolution opposing the amendment that would have banned it.
“It’s a tool,” Kitigan Zibi Chief Dylan Whiteduck said about the list of banned guns. “It’s not a weapon.”
The government is going to face similar pushback from Indigenous hunters if it tries to ban the SKS again.
The advisory group that Prime Minister Mark Carney put in charge of firearms classification, including the SKS, hasn’t met yet. When it does, banning the SKS shouldn’t be on the agenda.
The government couldn’t deliver on this program in the minors; it shouldn’t be giving itself a call-up to the big leagues. It still won’t work and taxpayers will still pay the price.
Is Canada Off Track?
Canada has problems. You see them at gas station. You see them at the grocery store. You see them on your taxes.
Is anyone listening to you to find out where you think Canada’s off track and what you think we could do to make things better?
You can tell us what you think by filling out the survey
Franco Terrazzano
Federal Director
Hey, it’s Franco.
Did you know that you can get the inside scoop right from my notebook each week? I’ll share hilarious and infuriating stories the media usually misses with you every week so you can hold politicians accountable.
You can sign up for our Action Update emails
We take data security and privacy seriously. Your information will be kept safe.